top of page

Holiday Desserts

Holiday pies are available for pickup on November 25th. Please select your pickup date before adding items to your cart - items will display as unavailable until your pickup date is selected. Happy Holidays!

Accepting Orders
Pickup time: Nov 14, 5:00 PM - 5:15 PM
Pickup Address: 104 North Main Street, Pleasant Gap, PA 16823-3106

Merry Morsels

Orders from this menu can only be scheduled for November 25, 2026.

Celebrate the season with our festive holiday desserts! From rich, comforting pies bursting with classic flavors to a selection of freshly baked cookies perfect for sharing (or savoring solo). Each treat is crafted to bring joy and sweetness to your holiday table.

Cozy Crusts

Orders from this section can only be scheduled for November 25, 2026.

Celebrate the season with our homemade holiday pies! Each pie is baked fresh with classic, comforting flavors perfect for your Holiday table. Order ahead and pick up your pies—your holiday dessert just got a whole lot easier.

Banoffee Pie

Our most popular pie! Cookie crust with dulce de leche, fresh bananas, whipped topping, sprinkled with our house-made pretzel crunch.

$32.00 - Unavailable

Dutch, Bourbon Caramel Apple Pie

Bourbon Dutch Apple Pie - An all-butter crust piled high with fresh apples and layered with house-made bourbon caramel. Finished with a buttery brown sugar crumb topping and a generous drizzle of bourbon caramel after baking.

$35.00 - Unavailable

After Hours Bourbon Pecan Praline Pie

A decadent pecan praline pie loaded with buttery toasted pecans, rich brown sugar, and a generous splash of bourbon. Sweet, sticky, and definitely not an early bedtime kind of dessert.

$35.00 - Unavailable

814-359-2082

104 N Main St
Pleasant Gap, PA 16823

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

©2022 by Red Horse Tavern. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page